4.2 Types of Trade Protection

Download Questions

Trade protection refers to policies and practices that governments use to protect their domestic industries from foreign competition. These measures can include tariffs, quotas, subsidies, and various administrative barriers. The objective is typically to shield local businesses from international competition, preserve jobs, and maintain national security in certain industries.

Definition:
A tariff is a tax imposed by a government on imported goods and services. Tariffs are among the oldest forms of trade protection and are used to increase the cost of imported goods, making them less competitive compared to domestically produced goods.
Real-World Example:
The U.S. imposed tariffs on steel and aluminum imports in 2018 to protect its domestic industries. This led to higher costs for U.S. manufacturers that rely on these inputs, and other countries retaliated with tariffs on U.S. exports, affecting global trade relations.

Protect Domestic Industries: By making imported goods more expensive, tariffs encourage consumers to buy domestic products.
Revenue Generation: Governments can generate income from tariffs, which can be significant for developing countries.
Correct Trade Imbalances: Tariffs can reduce imports, potentially helping to correct trade deficits.

Specific Tariff: A fixed fee per unit of imported goods, e.g., $5 per kilogram of cheese.
Ad Valorem Tariff: A percentage of the value of the imported goods, e.g., 10% of the value of a car.
- Effects
On Consumers: Higher prices for imported goods lead to reduced consumer surplus and decreased demand for these goods.
On Domestic Producers: Increased protection allows domestic producers to raise prices and increase production, leading to higher producer surplus.
On Government: Generates revenue but can also lead to retaliation by other countries.
On Foreign Producers: Reduced competitiveness in the domestic market due to higher prices.
On Global Welfare: Overall, tariffs lead to deadweight loss, reduced trade volumes, and potential trade wars.

Definition:
A quota is a quantitative limit on the amount of a specific good that can be imported into a country. Unlike tariffs, quotas directly restrict the quantity rather than raising the price of goods.
Purpose:
Protect Domestic Producers: Limits the amount of foreign goods, ensuring a larger market share for domestic producers.
Control Market Saturation: Prevents the market from being flooded with foreign goods, which could depress prices.
Manage Balance of Payments: Helps in controlling the volume of imports, potentially improving the trade balance.

Absolute Quota: A strict limit on the quantity of goods that can be imported.
Tariff-Rate Quota: A combination of quotas and tariffs where a lower tariff rate applies to imports within the quota, and a higher rate applies to imports that exceed the quota.
Effects:
On Consumers: Limited supply of certain goods can lead to higher prices and reduced variety.
On Domestic Producers: Reduced foreign competition allows for higher production and potentially higher prices.
On Foreign Producers: Restricted access to the market can lead to reduced sales and potential losses.
On Government: No direct revenue generation unless licenses are auctioned or sold.
On Global Welfare: Similar to tariffs, quotas result in deadweight loss and market inefficiencies.
Real-World Example:
The U.S. has set quotas on sugar imports to protect its domestic sugar industry. As a result, U.S. consumers pay higher prices for sugar compared to the world market, but the domestic industry is shielded from global competition.

Definition:
Export subsidies are financial supports provided by governments to local firms to encourage them to sell their goods and services abroad. These subsidies can take the form of direct payments, tax relief, or discounted inputs.
Real-World Example:
The European Union's Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) provides subsidies to EU farmers to encourage agricultural exports. This has led to disputes with other countries, such as the U.S. and Brazil, who argue that these subsidies distort global agricultural markets.

Purpose

Boost Exports: Make domestic goods cheaper in foreign markets, increasing their competitiveness.
Support Domestic Employment: By promoting exports, subsidies can help maintain or increase employment in export-oriented industries.
Improve Trade Balance: Increase the volume of exports, potentially improving the trade balance.

Types of Export Subsidies:

Direct Subsidies: Cash payments to exporters.
Indirect Subsidies: Tax breaks, reduced-cost inputs, or government-funded marketing support.

Effects

On Domestic Producers: Increased competitiveness in foreign markets leads to higher sales and revenue.
On Government: High financial costs due to subsidies, which may strain public finances.
On Consumers (Domestic): May face higher prices for goods as more products are exported, reducing domestic supply.
On Foreign Producers: Faces reduced competitiveness as subsidized goods from other countries flood their markets.
On Global Welfare: Can lead to trade disputes and retaliatory measures, distorting international trade and potentially leading to inefficiencies.

Definition:
Administrative barriers refer to a variety of regulatory measures that governments use to restrict imports. These barriers can include customs procedures, product standards, and licensing requirements, among others.
Real-World Example:
Japan has been known for its strict regulatory standards on food imports, which has been cited as a barrier for foreign producers trying to enter the Japanese market. For example, Japan’s stringent pesticide residue limits have been a hurdle for many agricultural exporters.

Customs Procedures: Complex, lengthy, or expensive customs checks can delay or increase the cost of imports.
Product Standards: Strict health, safety, or environmental regulations that imported goods must meet, which may differ significantly from international norms.
Licensing Requirements: Requirements that importers obtain special licenses, which may be difficult to acquire.
Other Technical Barriers: Includes packaging, labeling, or marketing restrictions that can make it difficult for foreign goods to compete in the domestic market.

Protect Consumers: Ensure that imported goods meet high standards of safety, health, and quality.
Protect Domestic Industries: By imposing difficult-to-meet standards or complex procedures, governments can effectively reduce the competitiveness of foreign goods.
Promote National Security: Restrict imports of certain goods that are deemed critical to national security.

On Consumers: Reduced availability of foreign goods, often leading to higher prices and less variety.
On Domestic Producers: Reduced competition from foreign goods, leading to higher market share and potential price increases.
On Foreign Producers: Increased costs and challenges in entering the domestic market.
On Government: Administrative costs to enforce these barriers, but no direct revenue is generated.
On Global Welfare: Leads to market inefficiencies and can spark trade disputes with other countries.